A lokacin da kake kula da gidanka , sau da yawa ka fara da babban ra'ayi, kuma waɗannan manyan ra'ayoyin suna raguwa kamar yadda gaskiyar ta same ka a fuska. Lokacin da kake ƙoƙarin yin hukunci a tsakanin katako na fira-ciment kamar HardiePlank tare da mafi mahimmanci madadin maye gurbin vinyl, amsar zai zama da sauƙi idan duk abubuwan sun kasance daidai.
A duk yankuna sai dai farashin, HardiePlank da ɗayan allon firam-ciment mafi kyau shine mai nasara a kan vinyl siding.
Amma kamar yadda abubuwa da yawa ke da alaka da gida, wadannan lambobin sun riga sun wuce ta alamar dollar wanda zai iya canza shawararka da sauri a wata hanya daban.
1. Girma
A cikin Brief : HardiePlank yana da muhimmanci sosai fiye da na vinyl.
HardiePlank yana da tsalle , kamar dai itace mai tsabta. Yayinda lokutuwa suka bambanta, matsakaici na HardiePlank yana da 5/16 ", ko kuma rabin lokaci (0.25").
Ya bambanta, ramin vinyl yana da zurfi: tsakanin 0.040 da .046 inci m. Wannan yana nufin cewa shingen vinyl yana kusa da 2 2/2 lokacin da ya fi tsanani HardiePlank.
Game da bayyanar waje, ko da yake, kauri ba ya da mahimmanci, sai dai a cikin yanayin rubutu (a ƙasa). Da zarar an shigar da kayayyakin biyu a gida, ba za ka iya ganin cikakkiyar kauri ba. Game da karko (har ila yau), kauri yana da kwayar halitta.
2. Famarawa
A takaitaccen bayani : Wutar ruwan inabi ta fi zafi da zafi da zafi fiye da HardiePlank.
HardiePlank ya hada da kayan ciminti kamar kimanin 10% zuwa 15% cellulose (itace). Masu kwangila suna gunaguni saboda ginin fiti-ciment ya kaddamar da girgije na yumbu. Dole ne a kula da kulawa mai girma, tun da yake yin ƙurar ƙura zai iya haifar da silicosis mai tsanani.
Amma jin zafi shine kashin ku: HardiePlank ba zai ƙone ba.
James Hardie Industries ya ɗauki HardiePlank - kuma a gaskiya, duk kayan aikin fiber-ciment - kada su kasance "fashewa ko flammable."
An shayar da muryar Vinyl tare da jinkirin wuta, amma wannan yana jinkirta ko jinkirin rage yaduwar wuta. Masu aikin wuta a wani lokuta suna yin sharhi game da yadda gidajensu da magunguna na vinyl suke kusa da gidan mai konewa - har zuwa ƙafafu 60 - ba za su yi amfani da ita ba saboda maganin zafi.
3. Rubutun kalmomi
A Brief : Domin HardiePlank ya fi tsayi, yana ba da izini don zurfafa rubutun fiye da yadda ake yin vinyl siding.
HardiePlank ta kauri yana ba da damar yin amfani da gwaninta, don haka yana kama da itace.
Abincin Vinyl kullum yana da taimako na itace, amma samfurin yana da bakin ciki don ba da izini ga launi mai zurfi da aka samo akan HardiePlank (ko itace na ainihi, don wannan abu).
4. Kudin
A takaitaccen bayani : Gizon vinyl yana kusan koda yaushe yana da tsada fiye da shinge-ciment.
Rikicin Vinyl yana da rahusa - duka biyu dangane da samfurin da farashin aiki. Ɗaya daga cikin ka'idojin yatsa: matsakaicin da za ku iya tsammanin ku biya bashin vinyl shi ne mafi ƙarancin da za ku iya sa ran biya ga HardiePlank da sauran kayayyakin shinge.
CostHelper yayi rahoton cewa vinyl siding a kan na 1,800-square feet na waje na iya ƙila a matsayin low as $ 3,600 kuma kamar yadda high as $ 12,600 kuma sama ga masu sana'a sun rataye vinyl.
Don murabba'in filayen mita 1,250, za ku iya tsammanin ku biya dolar Amirka dubu 13, ko kimanin $ 10 a kowace kafafu.
5. Durability
A Brief : HardiePlank da kuma vinyl siding kowannensu yana da nasarorin dasu da kuma fursunoni, amma a kan dukan hardiePlank za a iya la'akari da su kasance mafi m.
Vinyl siding da HardiePlank duka suna da matukar tasiri, mai satar itace (wanda yake buƙatar ɗaukar hoto) da shakewar shake (wanda ke buƙatar magani na yau da kullum).
Dukansu samfurori ba su da kishi ga kwari masu lalacewa - tururuwa da ma'adinai musamman - kuma tsuntsaye kamar bishiyoyi. Idan mazaunin lokaci sun fara cinye gida tare da ko wane shinge, suna da sha'awar kayan kayan da aka samo a cikin wasu abubuwa masu gine-gine - katako na itace, bishiyoyi da shavings, shafukan OSB .
Kowace samfurin ba shi da kyau a hanyarsu.
Hanyar hanyar da vinyl siding ta rushe shi ne lokacin da wani ɓoye mai laushi ko lambun gonar ya rushe siding, ya raye rami ko samar da gas. Sakamakon yanayin zafi yana sa shingen vinyl ya fi dacewa da fatattaka. Kamar yadda muka gani a baya, zafi zai warwatse shi. Sanya barbecue ma kusa da vinyl siding kuma za a raye bayan gyara (sauyawa shine gyara kawai).
HardiePlank, kasancewa mai mahimmanci na takarda, zai zama mai tasiri. Ba zai warke ko narke ba.